Losing Belly Fat, Whether from a Low-Carb or a Low-Fat Diet, Helps Improve Blood Vessel Function

[iBurger]

ScienceDaily (Mar. 13, 2012) — Overweight people who shed pounds, especially belly fat, can improve the function of their blood vessels no matter whether they are on a low-carb or a low-fat diet, according to a study being presented by Johns Hopkins researchers at an American Heart Association scientific meeting in San Diego on March 13 that is focused on cardiovascular disease prevention.

In the six-month weight-loss study, Hopkins researchers found that the more belly fat the participants lost, the better their arteries were able to expand when needed, allowing more blood to flow more freely. The researchers also found that participants in the study who were on a low-carb diet lost about ten pounds more, on average, than those who were on a low-fat diet. Being overweight increases the risk of cardiovascular disease, especially if the fat is accumulated in the belly above the waist.
"After six months, those who were on the low-carb diet lost an average of 28.9 pounds versus 18.7 pounds among those on the low-fat diet," says lead investigator Kerry J. Stewart, Ed.D., a professor of medicine at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine and director of clinical and research exercise physiology at the Johns Hopkins Heart and Vascular Institute.
Stewart and his colleagues studied 60 men and women who weighed an average of 215 pounds at the start of the program. Half of the participants went on a low-carb diet while the others followed a low-fat diet. All took part in moderate exercise and their diets provided a similar amount of calories each day.
In order to evaluate the health of the participants' blood vessels before and after the weight loss program, the researchers conducted a blood flow test by constricting circulation in the upper arm for five minutes with a blood pressure cuff. With this type of test, when the cuff is released, a healthier artery will expand more, allowing more blood to flow through the artery. The researchers measured how much blood reached the fingertips before, during, and after the constriction of the artery. Stewart says this test can give an indication of the overall health of the vascular system throughout the body. The researchers found that the more belly fat a person had lost, the greater the blood flow to the finger, signaling better the function of the artery.
"Our study demonstrated that the amount of improvement in the vessels was directly linked to how much central, or belly fat, the individuals lost, regardless of which diet they were on," says Stewart. "This is important since there have been concerns that a low-carb diet, which means eating more fat, may have a harmful effect on cardiovascular health. These results showed no harmful effects from the low-carb diet."
In the low-carb diet used in the study, up to 30 percent of calories came from carbs such as bread, pasta and certain fruits, while 40 percent was from fat consumed from meat, dairy products and nuts. In contrast, the low-fat diet consisted of no more than 30 percent of calories from fat and 55 percent from carbs.
Stewart notes that participants on the low-carb diet lost more weight and at a faster pace, on average, which has also been seen in several other studies. He says eating higher amounts of carbohydrates can slow down the rate of body fat loss while on a weight reduction diet.
The findings were consistent with early results presented by Stewart in June 2011 at the annual meeting of the American College of Sports Medicine in Denver. That initial report was based on results after participants in the study had lost their first 10 pounds. These longer-term results show that weight loss, along with exercise, is important for improving vascular health, and suggests following a low-carb diet rather than the conventionally recommended low-fat diet for weight loss is not a concern in terms of vascular health.

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/03/120313230314.htm

Klik om meer te lezen...

 

[Fatshredder]

Ja, toch weer lowcarb > lowfat. Maar het ging hier natuurlijk om cardiovasculaire effecten en gewichtsverlies in het algemeen. Ons is het natuurlijk niet perse zomaar om gewichtsverlies te doen, waardoor conclusies alweer lastiger worden.

 

[Gouwetonny]

Volgens mij trekt dit onderzoek op niks. Iemand het betreffende artikel?

 

[ignition]

Volgens mij trekt dit onderzoek op niks. Iemand het betreffende artikel?

Klik om te verkleinen...

Hm, bij 95% van alle onderzoeken die low-carb en low-fat vergelijken komt low-carb als winnaar uit de bus als we alleen kijken naar gewichtsverlies. Samen met verbeterde bloedwaarden: hogere HDL, lagere trygliceriden, betere bloeddruk. LDL is meestal niet significant hoger in de low-carb groep maar de lagere triglyceriden impliceren dat de LDL partikels groter zijn en dus minder schadelijk. Waarom zou deze studie dan op niks trekken? Ze vindt hetzelfde als het merendeel van de andere studies.

 

[Gouwetonny]

Hm, bij 95% van alle onderzoeken die low-carb en low-fat vergelijken komt low-carb als winnaar uit de bus als we alleen kijken naar gewichtsverlies. Samen met verbeterde bloedwaarden: hogere HDL, lagere trygliceriden, betere bloeddruk. LDL is meestal niet significant hoger in de low-carb groep maar de lagere triglyceriden impliceren dat de LDL partikels groter zijn en dus minder schadelijk. Waarom zou deze studie dan op niks trekken? Ze vindt hetzelfde als het merendeel van de andere studies.

Klik om te verkleinen...

Dat zal best ja, bedoelde de rest van het stukje tekst.

 

[ignition]

Dat zal best ja, bedoelde de rest van het stukje tekst.

Klik om te verkleinen...

Dat de functie van hun bloedvaten verbetert als ze afvallen? Lijkt me ook niet zo abnormaal. Waarom denk je dat het onderzoek op niks trekt?

 

[Gouwetonny]

Dat de functie van hun bloedvaten verbetert als ze afvallen? Lijkt me ook niet zo abnormaal. Waarom denk je dat het onderzoek op niks trekt?

Klik om te verkleinen...

Vaak zijn dit onderzoeken met kleine populaties waarin er er veel variabelen worden genegeerd.

Maar als je het onderzoek kan vinden lees ik het graag eens door.

Scopus geeft namelijk geen hits.

 

[Robjee]

="Gouwetonny"Iemand het betreffende artikel?

Klik om te verkleinen...

Volgens mij zijn de resultaten alleen maar gepresenteerd tijdens een "meeting":

"Overweight people who shed pounds, especially belly fat, can improve the function of their blood vessels no matter whether they are on a low-carb or a low-fat diet, according to a study being presented by Johns Hopkins researchers at an American Heart Association scientific meeting in San Diego on March 13 that is focused on cardiovascular disease prevention."

In ieder geval is er geen publicatie van hem daarover te vinden:
http://www.hopkinsbayview.org/cardiology/faculty/stewart.html

Hij lijkt overigens vaker resultaten op een dergelijke manier te presenteren:

"The findings were consistent with early results presented by Stewart in June 2011 at the annual meeting of the American College of Sports Medicine in Denver."